Not A Bug Slay Undead Proc rate broken

Discussion in 'Resolved' started by Tutankamen, Dec 20, 2019.

  1. Dahaman Augur


    Here is a bug thread about Holy Forge. It more or less concurs with your statement.

    https://forums.daybreakgames.com/eq...-disc-holyforge-level-55.266375/#post-3917611
  2. Wulfhere Augur

    Here is a parse against an even con, level 60, undead with CF3 and SU3 and Holyforge. The fight took longer then HF's duration. I think the net gain from using 30% of my endurance was effectively nothing (again).

    Holyforge is a fruitless disc pre-PoP and should be improved for TLP players, meaning the class should have a useful disc besides Sanctification and Fearless for 3 expansions (because for the past many years it hasn't). Paladin does has neither defensive or offensive disc (vs Melee) as things stand, during Kunark, Velious, and Luclin.

    [Tue Mar 30 14:05:13 2021] You activate Holyforge Discipline.

    [Tue Mar 30 14:05:23 2021] You pierce Xi Thall for 247 points of damage. (Critical)
    [Tue Mar 30 14:09:57 2021] You bash Xi Thall for 56 points of damage. (Critical)

    [Tue Mar 30 14:07:53 2021] You pierce Xi Thall for 518 points of damage. (Crippling Blow)
    [Tue Mar 30 14:09:41 2021] You pierce Xi Thall for 273 points of damage. (Crippling Blow)

    [Tue Mar 30 14:07:22 2021] You pierce Xi Thall for 1031 points of damage. (Slay Undead)
    [Tue Mar 30 14:07:45 2021] You pierce Xi Thall for 1031 points of damage. (Slay Undead)
    [Tue Mar 30 14:10:03 2021] You pierce Xi Thall for 1031 points of damage. (Slay Undead)

    [Tue Mar 30 14:10:15 2021] The holy light fades from your weapon.

    /tell Total Paladin -vs- Xi Thall: -- DMG: 32212 -- DPS: 82 -- Scaled: 82 -- Pierce: 18522 -- DirDmg: 6053 -- Environmental: 2995 -- DoT: 2875 -- Slash: 1336 -- Bash: 431 -- % dmg as normal: 96.6% -- % dmg as critical: 0.9% -- Non-crit rate: 98.8% -- crit rate: 0.6% -- crippling rate: 0.6% -- Attempts: 435 -- Hits: 340 -- Missed: 84 -- Defended: 11 -- Accuracy: 80.2% -- Avg Hit: 94 -- Max hit: 1031 -- DMG to PC: 14579
  3. niente Developer

    Some interesting discussion and parses here. Slay Undead is not currently bugged - the proc rate is working as expected. Holyforge is not a very useful discipline, but it's not broken. I will ask about Holyforge being tuned to be less bad.
    Xanadas, Zinth and Wulfhere like this.

Share This Page