Category: Tradeskills [Can Repro] Date/Time: Wed Aug 17 15:51:08 2022 Character: Level 120 Monk (Main) Zone: The Plane of Knowledge Location: -349.99, 773.94, -90.42, 505.18 Description: The recipe for "Breaded Storm Salmon" (1 Storm Salmon, 1 Bread Crumbs, 1 Garnish, 1 Jug of Sauces) produces and learns as "Storm Salmon Fillet," which requires 1 Storm Salmon + 1 Jug of Sauces
When trying to combine the following, File, Rhenium Ore, Smithy Hammer, to create, Rhenium Fill, a component needed to Craft an Intricate Sap there is a failure. Instead of crafting the, Rhenium Fill, and returning the file and smithy Hammer, it yields, Rhenium barbs and returns the file, but it consumes the smithy hammer. I had to buy several smithy hammers to try the recipe again, but it happens every time. This result is incorrect. It should yield the Rhenium Fill, and return the file and Smithy Hammer.
I just tested this on Povar. If I experiment, manually place the items in the forge, I get Rhenium Barbs and lose the smithy hammer as Fezzelwhiq described. If I use my previously learned recipe by selecting it in the UI, it works just fine. I get Rhenium Fill instead and my smithy hammer is correctly returned. I get the same results with Cobalt Ore and Cobalt Fill. If I experiment, I get Barbs and lose the hammer. if I use the known recipe in the UI, it works. Ditto with Scorched, tantalum, vanadium and titanium.
Working JC in WFP did a short run of combines, moved to do gold malachite but wont let me. Gives me message Searching favorite recipes. Logged out all the way, zoned, destroyed bag bought new one....Still unable to do combines Lenwu Yelinak Server
Yeah don't report another recipe for an issue on a non-related sub-combine. https://www.eqtraders.com/items/show_item.php?item=31407&menustr=035000000000 It looks like one of the TS bugs from test may have made it to live. A combine failure should not yield the item you are trying to make, but return the tools used. A failure should be returning smithy hammer instead of a barb.
You should be able to buy Intricate Weapon Smithing to learn this recipe without experimenting and then use the UI to search/make the recipe? Edit: apparently not. You do learn the fill recipe for the higher items through scribing the books, but not intricate. Sorry.
I don't think these are failures returning the wrong item. As I described - if I use the UI it works just fine. If I experiment it doesn't. Additionally, I can confirm that during experimenting for Vanadium, I DID fail and I received the message "You lacked the skills to fashion Vanadium Barbs"...
I have found another recipe bug with Fletching. I was trying to craft an, Intricate Mace. Combining, 3 Knot Measuring String, Ashwood Bowstave, Fine Silk, Planing Tool, in a fletching kit and instead of getting, Intricate Short Haft, and the Planing Tool(1), 3 Knot Measuring String(1) I just get 4 knot measuring string and nothing else. I tried multiple times with the same result each time. If this helps, it's Trivial at: 184 and my skill level is 228, It did not say it failed in the text. It just says that I fashioned the items to create something new 4 knot measuring string. I did the combine in standard Fletching Kit.
This boils down to "issues with TS recipe combines", it would be better to have all the recipe issues in one thread so all the information is in one place if they have to end up hunting these down one by one.
You said failure in your OP so it read like you were saying you lose the hammer on a failed combine. Yes you cannot continue to the recipe that uses the Fill, but the Fill recipe is standalone and that is the one thats not coming out. They need to look at the Fill recipe, not the Sap recipe (though it sounds like theres a "off by one" bit error for any TS combines so its likely you wouldnt get the Sap on combine either once you have the Filll). You wouldnt go to your mechanic and tell them you cant start your car up, when you are locked out.
TS issues from test were not completely corrected and leaked over. If you have the recipe learned already dont manually combine. https://forums.daybreakgames.com/eq/index.php?threads/intricate-sap-recipe-bug.284986/#post-4160537
If you have the recipe learned already, dont manually combine. https://forums.daybreakgames.com/eq/index.php?threads/intricate-sap-recipe-bug.284986/#post-4160537
I understand. I'm new to posting, Thank you for the clarification. I'll keep it in mind for future posts.
In a general sense yes unrelated bugs should each have their own thread, but in this case its a failure of the whole TS system that came over from test (was reported as fixed for live but here we are).
