love your points. i will need to look into the total hp for carapace HA. id only like to counter one argument. that being the medic being on par or slightly worse then HA...this has been a problem for a long time and as far as im concerned it also should be a thing. medics are a support class. they support other classes to head a fight, not to pursue the fight themselves. this is a point that should be upheld in ANY game with a medic. it is soooo tiresome to see medics getting in gunfights rather then revives and healing, i see this very very often. when i made the switch from nc to tr a couple years back i realized that the tr's medic organization was just better. they did their jobs as medics. but shortly, i dont believe medics should ever come close to an equal fight with any class same as infis their role is specific and abundant and doesnt require combat.