No, you are correct. Even the guy responsible for querying the server for those stats agrees, albeit tacitly. This is not a game where K/D matters. A medic hiding behind a spawn shield racking up a massive K/D, SPM and accuracy really might be a terrible player. These "all-star"events really do the game no favors, especially since the everyday PS2 player can't replicate the conditions in the game. This game isn't ready for MLG, because this game hasn't reached a state where it can ensure even conditions for all factions involved.