I'm a bit confused as to why it is unfair. First, not every Permafrost toon was created at launch, I'm sure there are people there who will lose names of characters created recently. Second, you seem to be overlooking the fact that the characters on Permafrost are in fact older. They have been playing longer. Had you started playing earlier, you'd have had toons on an older server as well. The fact that you started on a server that didn't exist at launch, is an indication you haven't played as long.