Tank Shawl 2.0 versus 3.0, is 3.0 proc rate okay?

Discussion in 'Tanks' started by Kurayami, Apr 29, 2013.

  1. Kurayami Augur

    So done a little bit of the shawl 3.0 quests, but not sure if I really want to continue after hearing about how the casters/priests got the screwdown with their shawl. As I understand it, the 2.0 proc is 750 rune, while 3.0 is an 850 rune? Not much of a boost though if the proc rate on 3.0 is the crap. Does anyone know if the proc rate is the same or better on the 3.0 shawl as 2.0? I see no point in bothering to upgrade if the 3.0 is in fact a downgrade, any information on this would be greatly appreciated.
  2. Mykaylla Augur

    Raid shawl 2.0:

    [20557] Sacred Defending Courage of Brell
    Target: Self
    Beneficial: Blockable
    Casting: 0s
    Duration: 06:00:00 (3600 ticks), Extend: No
    1: Cast on Skill Use: Brell's Sacred Stone Balm (22% Chance)
    2: Limit Skill: Dodge
    Has a chance to cast a rune every time the dodge skill is used.
    [20558] Brell's Sacred Stone Balm
    Target: Self
    Beneficial: Blockable
    Casting: 0s
    Duration: 60s (10 ticks), Extend: No
    7: Absorb Damage: 100% Total: 850
    Text: You are fortified by Brell's Stone Balm.

    Group shawl 2.0:

    [20546] Blessed Defending Courage of Brell
    Target: Self
    Beneficial: Blockable
    Casting: 0s
    Duration: 06:00:00 (3600 ticks), Extend: No
    1: Cast on Skill Use: Brell's Blessed Stone Balm (22% Chance)
    2: Limit Skill: Dodge
    Has a chance to cast a rune every time the dodge skill is used.
    [20547] Brell's Blessed Stone Balm
    Target: Self
    Beneficial: Blockable
    Casting: 0s
    Duration: 60s (10 ticks), Extend: No
    7: Absorb Damage: 100% Total: 750
    Text: You are fortified by Brell's Stone Balm.

    Raid shawl 3.0:

    [38560] Brell's Might
    Target: Self
    Beneficial: Blockable
    Casting: 0s
    Duration: 06:00:00 (3600 ticks), Extend: No
    1: Cast on Skill Use: Brell's Sacred Stone Balm (22% Chance)
    2: Limit Skill: Dodge
    Has a chance to cast a rune every time the dodge skill is used.
    [20558] Brell's Sacred Stone Balm
    Target: Self
    Beneficial: Blockable
    Casting: 0s
    Duration: 60s (10 ticks), Extend: No
    7: Absorb Damage: 100% Total: 850
    Text: You are fortified by Brell's Stone Balm.

    Group shawl 3.0:

    [38556] Brell's Strength
    Target: Self
    Beneficial: Blockable
    Casting: 0s
    Duration: 06:00:00 (3600 ticks), Extend: No
    1: Cast on Skill Use: Brell's Blessed Stone Balm (22% Chance)
    2: Limit Skill: Dodge
    Has a chance to cast a rune every time the dodge skill is used.
    [20547] Brell's Blessed Stone Balm
    Target: Self
    Beneficial: Blockable
    Casting: 0s
    Duration: 60s (10 ticks), Extend: No
    7: Absorb Damage: 100% Total: 750
    Text: You are fortified by Brell's Stone Balm.

    The procs are identical to the group and raid versions of the last shawl. Same chance, same size.
    The big draw of this shawl is that it is a 50AC 300 hp 7 HDex 7HAgi augment for the group version, and a 55AC 350 hp 8 HDex 8 HAgi aug for the raid version.
  3. Kurayami Augur

    I see, guess I should have noticed the part about (22% Chance) . Not real keen about going from raid proc to group proc though until several months later. Sidegrade here I come, apparently.
  4. Mykaylla Augur

    If you really want the additional 100 pts on the rune, and don't mind the stat hit of using your 2.0 shawl, you can do all of the shawl quest up to the point where you have to tailor the shawl of the duke, and just don't do that final step, until you have your raid drop.
  5. Riou EQResource

    Group shawl 3.0 is best Tank Aug in game and wont be replaced for like 5 years, should definitely move up to it.