This achievement is not being granted on the turn-in of the 4 Dull Pearl Necklaces dropped from the Nybright sisters in Lesser Faydark to a drunkard in Greater Faydark. They're lore, so it's easy to tell if you have all four, but I've confirmed each of them are associated with one of the four sisters. I've tried doing the turn-in twice now (all four necklaces at once). Success text is given and experience is rewarded, but the achievement is not awarded. Walk-through if needed: https://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=88 Edit: This is completable, but it's questionable as to if the turn-in of elven wine should be required since there are two lead-ins to the quest, one of which does not require the elven wine.