When asked if a caster can do the quest, you answered, "Yes, but this may be misleading." Does this mean a caster can get the reward, but not use it?
Yes! Fun fact: Did you know it only takes 4 wrath orc wristbands to get a Barbarian woman in bed? As discovered in the quest "The Seax", Lysbith McNaff tells you the following: "If ye can return to me four wrath orc wristbands from the troopers' bodies, I'll reward ye with the [Seax].'" Obviously the A in Seax is silent....
Recognition to Igorath-Bertox who posted the weapon name "Seax", while I was in the confirmation process of posting the quest name as given on Alla: "The Seax". Between then and now, Igorath-Bertox has deleted that post.