Recap Yes Would Duder or any other troll likely eat it? Is it something that one would place in inventory? Is it looted from a dead npc? Is this item part of a quest? Does it appear automatically in your bags when a mob dies?- Pretty much No Is it an NPC? Would it be tasty to a troll? - At least I don't think so, but I do think they would eat it. Would the item actually be able to be consumed as food by non-trolls. - In terms of EQ mechanics, your character can't eat it. Is this in original Everquest?