My brain is not THAT twisted! If going into the deep inner workings of anyone's brain is a dark path, it would be your brain! It would take something kinda gross to cause this item to be considered "poopable", but I suppose in a metaphysical sense, it could be. But I would prefer not to think that.
The quest was for sure introduced in 2005, and since I only know of this specific item being related to this quest, that's what I'm going with. I will say that according to Allakhazam, the item was uploaded in a different year, but that may be because no one bothered to do it before. If you can narrow down which quest I'm referring to, the item is specifically mentioned in the quest write up on Allakhazam, and I personally have received this item.