That wasn't what was said. Specifically it was stated no cleric should ever do more DPS than a rogue without any note of equally geared, etc. I expressly compared a cleric with the best gear gear and optimisation vs a marginally played rogue with bad gear with the intent of implying the same level against the same target. Yes, equally geared, leveled, and played rogue vs cleric, the rogue should have better DPS because the cleric does have other skills they bring to a group against challenging content. AND, I am entirely sure that in that comparison, a rogue does do better DPS than the cleric even if the rogue's DPS shoul be increased.