From what I've heard, being sticklers for details is the least of their issues. Many in leadership positions have become corrupt and act like tyrants, there is a lot of elitism/gatekeeping and outright horrible behavior that gets tolerated. Basically the club became to big, bringing the concept of politics which then lead to corruption and scandal (money, sexual harassment, etc.). They have completely lost the purpose of the club, which was to just have fun with your love of Star Wars and geekdom with others like you. There is a youtube channel named Rexin_Around that did a group discussion last month, with people who have been members, talking about a lot of the issues. The ever interesting youtube algorithm just popped it up for me.