Well if you kept your subscription going past October you were rewarded by getting the free emblem cache, unless of course you weren't because you cancelled your sub... I mean you cancelled your sub... why should you be rewarded for anything? In fact they didn't have to reward people that cancelled their sub prior to October either, they just chose too, it's not even so much a reward as it is more a "promotion" to try and get them back in to the game to spend money, spun as a gift. Marketing 101. The truth is if you're not prepared to keep up your sub then you run the risk of "missing out on subscription gifts" and if you cancel your subscription you have zero right to anything other than what you outright purchase. People know most gifts go to the most loyal players and that's subscribers. If you're not prepared to put the 50c per day in to support a game that you clearly enjoy given how incensed you are over all of this then I don't know what to say... re-prioritize perhaps.